Research  ·  UI Redesign  ·  Usability Testing

Monetization
Transparency
Research.

This case study is a research-led exploration of how streaming platforms can be clearer about what a subscription actually covers, using Amazon Prime Video as the test case. Working alongside Ashley Sinclair and Armando Troisi, I helped lead the research, design three independent interface concepts, and test each one with real users.

Each concept approached the same goal — making included and paid content easier to tell apart — through a different usability lens. We measured all three against user feedback and Prime Video's own business goals before recommending a direction.

Role UX Researcher & Designer
Responsibilities Research Usability Testing UI Design
Team 3 Designers
Project Type University Group Project
Tools Figma
Platforms Web
Constraints Small user sample (4–5 participants per round)
01  ·  Problem

An impressive catalogue, wrapped in confusion.

Spending time investigating the platform firsthand, we found that Amazon Prime Video offers an impressive variety of shows and movies — but it's genuinely unclear what's included in the subscription price, and what isn't.

Content Fragmentation

A mix of free-with-Prime, rental, and purchase titles sit side by side in the same rows, making it hard to tell what's included without clicking in — frustrating, and sometimes costly.

Intrusive Ads & Upselling

Ads and prompts to buy or rent content interrupt viewing, blurring the line between what the subscription already covers and what costs extra.

Poor Search & Discovery

Search results often lack clarity, and the overall browsing flow feels disorganized next to competitors like Netflix.

Illustrative mockup of a mid-browse upsell prompt reading 'Add [Service Name] to your Prime Membership, access more hits, exclusive shows, and movies'

The kind of mid-browse upsell prompt users described as confusing and easy to stop trusting.

02  ·  Primary Research

Grounding the redesign in how people actually use Prime Video.

My contribution

I worked alongside Ashley Sinclair and Armando Troisi through every phase of this project — desk research, user interviews, usability testing, and designing the three competing fixes we tested against Prime Video's real interface.

Project scope

Audit Prime Video's existing paywall and subscription patterns, design independent fixes grounded in different usability heuristics, and test each one with real users before recommending a direction.

Desk

Illustration of a researcher reviewing notes at a laptop

Researched existing Prime Video monetization case studies to see how the platform's paywalls and subscription upsells had already been studied and criticised.

Interviews

Illustration of two people talking, one asking 'What are your initial thoughts on this interface?'

Interviewed five Prime Video users about their first reactions to the homepage, and where the mix of included and paid content confused them.

Testing

Illustration of two people at a laptop, one saying 'Let's see, I need to click here...'

Ran usability testing sessions with five users across our three competing concepts, scoring each one against the same clarity and control metrics.

03  ·  Insights

What users actually told us.

Visibility of System Status

"Users feel the UI hides information."

Consistency and Standards

"Users are confused about what is included."

Consistency and Standards

"Users feel paywalls are unexpected, and poorly explained."

Freedom and Control

"Users don't feel in control of the system."

04  ·  Business Goals

Clarity has to survive contact with the business model.

Prime Video's own merchandising logic points the other way on some of these patterns — any fix we proposed had to hold up against goals the platform is already optimising for.

01

Mixed Content

Users tend to spend more when paid and free content are shown side by side in the same row.

02

Okay with Ugly

Denser, option-heavy pages can increase conversion for certain customer segments — clarity and conversion don't always pull in the same direction.

03

One-Way Doors

Removing back buttons at monetization decision points keeps users from second-guessing their way out of a purchase.

How might we improve clarity among Prime-included, subscription, and pay-per-title content — while still aligning with Prime Video's business goals?
05  ·  Design Proposal

Three concepts, three usability lenses.

We translated the research and business goals into three independent interface concepts — each solving the same transparency problem through a different heuristic. We prototyped and tested all three with real users before recommending a direction.

Concept 1  ·  Blackout

Make the unavailable look unavailable.

Visibility of System Status

Every row on Prime Video's homepage mixes titles you already have with titles you'd need another subscription to watch — with no visual difference between the two until you tap in. We dimmed unsubscribed cards with a scrim to signal they're currently unavailable, then added a centered service badge to telegraph exactly which paywall is waiting behind the tap.

Apple TV+ exclusive Hijack shown at full brightness among Prime Video's regular homepage rows Before
The same title dimmed with a scrim and a centered Apple TV app badge marking it as outside the Prime subscription After
Testing Results — 90% / 75% / 50% Opacity

We tested the scrim at three opacity levels with five users, scoring each on a 1–5 scale across four metrics.

Metric 90% Opacity 75% Opacity 50% Opacity
Clarity of Prime membership inclusion 4 4.33 4.67
Understanding show identity (pre-hover) 3 3.67 4.67
Did you expect the paywall? 4.67 4.67 4.33
Sense of control in purchase decision 5 5 5
Why 50% Opacity

50% won outright on clarity and show identity, and tied every condition on sense of control — with only a slightly lower score on whether users expected the paywall at all. We chose it as the strongest overall balance.

Concept 2  ·  Card Banner

Label the paywall instead of hiding it.

Visibility of System Status

Where Blackout subtracts information from unsubscribed cards, Card Banner adds it — a consistent coloured banner under every poster naming which service a title actually belongs to, standardised in colour, icon placement, and position across the whole grid.

Homepage rows showing Prime and Crave titles with inconsistent branding treatment Before
The same rows with a unified Paramount+ or Crave banner applied under every non-Prime title After
Testing Results — 4 Statements, 1–5 Scale
Statement Result
It was clear what was included, and what wasn't. Agree – Strongly Agree
The hover state double-confirmed my understanding. Agree – Strongly Agree
Icon choices are aligned with my understanding. Agree – Strongly Agree
The banner colours are not distracting. Agree – Strongly Agree
Open Feedback
  • Preferred Blackout's subtractive approach over Card Banner's additive one, on principle.
  • Visually clearer to see what was included and what wasn't.
  • The banner itself went largely unnoticed.
Concept 3  ·  Toggle

Surface the filter nobody noticed.

User Control and Freedom

Prime Video's interface already lets viewers filter between Prime-included and subscription content — but none of the people we interviewed knew the controls existed. We redesigned it as a single, brightly coloured toggle fixed in the main navigation.

Existing Prime Video navigation with the subscription filter tucked away as small icons in the top right Before
Redesigned navigation with a high-contrast blue toggle switch between Prime and Subscriptions After
Testing Results
  • 3 of 4 users still struggled to notice the toggle on first look.
  • Once they noticed it and understood what it did, users appreciated having an explicit way to sort Prime-included from additional content.
"I was looking at the page and I didn't notice the toggle at first." User 1
"It took me a while to see the toggle, I am used to looking for the icons." User 4
06  ·  Outcomes & Next Steps

One concept validated, two with a clear next move.

We tested all three concepts against an interactive Figma prototype ↗.

Blackout

Validated

Scored highest across the usability metrics we tracked. Next: test it against Prime Video's actual conversion and engagement data, not just usability scores.

Card Banner

Inconclusive

Tested just as clearly as Blackout, but users preferred a subtractive approach on principle. Next: redesign and retest the visual language before ruling it out.

Toggle

Needs Iteration

3 of 4 users missed it entirely on first look. Next: iterate on placement and visual weight, then test again.

07  ·  Reflection

What I'd do differently.

Test Discoverability Earlier

3 of 4 users missed the Toggle in testing. A quick round of guerrilla testing on the icon alone, before building the full flow around it, would have caught that earlier and cheaper.

Additive Isn't Always the Answer

Card Banner tested just as clearly as Blackout on paper, but informal feedback favoured Blackout's subtractive approach — a reminder that clarity sometimes comes from removing signal, not adding more of it.

Test Against the Business, Not Just the User

We validated Blackout with users but haven't yet tested it against Prime Video's actual conversion goals — the gap we flagged for ourselves going into the next round.